• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
OrthopaedicPrinciples.com

OrthopaedicPrinciples.com

Integrating Principles and Evidence

Integrating Principles and Evidence

  • Home
  • Editorial Board
  • Our Books
    • Evidence Based Orthopaedic Principles
  • Courses
  • Exams
  • Reviews
  • Live Program
  • Contact

Diagnosis of PJI – Practical Approach

Courtesy: Javad Parvizi, Ashok Shyam, IORG, OrthoTV

Topic / Overview

Diagnostic principles, historical evolution of consensus criteria, stepwise algorithmic workup, threshold cutoffs, and microbiological/molecular testing strategies for periprosthetic joint infection (PJI), based strictly on the provided lecture transcript.

Background / Problems

  • Absence of a Single Definitive Test: No single standalone test definitively confirms or excludes PJI, necessitating reliance on structured diagnostic criteria and clinical algorithms.

  • Index Case Illustration (Missed Low-Grade Infection): A 49-year-old patient underwent total knee arthroplasty (2018) after prior trauma, followed by arthroscopy (2020) and polyethylene exchange revision (2022) without adequate preoperative infection workup; intraoperative cultures were negative until overt PJI manifested in 2023.

  • Masquerading Pathology: An obvious mechanical explanation for pain (such as component loosening, polyethylene wear, or Adverse Local Tissue Reaction [ALTR] in metal-on-metal bearings) does not exclude concurrent infection. Metal-on-metal bearing surfaces are 9 to 14 times more likely to become infected.

  • Limitations of Traditional Cultures: Culture technology (dating to 1886) fails to isolate the pathogen in 20% to 40% of true PJI cases, as only 2% of known microorganisms are capable of growing on standard culture media.

Classification and Evolution of Diagnostic Criteria

1. Musculoskeletal Infection Society (MSIS) Criteria (2011 & 2018)

  • 2011 Original Criteria: Formulated by a multidisciplinary workgroup (orthopedic surgeons, musculoskeletal infectious disease specialists, and pathologists) to establish a standardized definition.

  • 2018 Validation & Revision: Incorporated pre-test probability and addressed three key gaps in the 2011 criteria:

    1. Recognized that individual diagnostic tests carry unequal diagnostic weight.

    2. Enabled preoperative diagnosis (earlier criteria relied partly on intraoperative minor criteria).

    3. Improved detection of less aggressive, slow-growing organisms.

2. European Bone and Joint Infection Society (EBJIS) Criteria (2021) — Speaker’s Critique

The speaker explicitly notes personal bias and outlines several limitations of the 2021 EBJIS definition:

  • Lack of formal validation.

  • Absence of a distinct definition for acute PJI (applying identical thresholds at 5 weeks post-arthroplasty and 10 years post-arthroplasty).

  • Exclusion of leukocyte esterase, ESR, and certain molecular markers.

  • Classification of a single positive culture as indicative of infection (despite frequent false-positive contaminants).

  • Inclusion of a “PJI likely” category and assignment of equal diagnostic weight across all tests.

3. The 2025 Unified Definition of PJI

  • Developed over 1.5 years through joint collaboration among MSIS, IDSA, ESCMID, ICM, and EBJIS.

  • Introduced in Istanbul in 2025 (with publication forthcoming in the New England Journal of Medicine) to replace all prior definitions with a single unified global standard.

Diagnostic Thresholds: Acute vs. Chronic PJI (ICM Criteria)

  • Unit Precaution: Serum CRP must be interpreted in milligrams per liter (mg/L) rather than milligrams per deciliter (mg/dL).

  • Acute PJI Thresholds:

    • Serum ESR: Not useful.

    • Serum CRP: Greater than 100 mg/L.

    • Synovial White Blood Cell (WBC) Count: Greater than 10,000 cells/µL.

    • Synovial Polymorphonuclear (PMN) Percentage: Greater than 90%.

  • Chronic PJI Thresholds:

    • Serum ESR: Greater than 30 mm/hr.

    • Serum CRP: Greater than 10 mg/L.

    • Synovial WBC Count: Greater than 3,000 cells/µL.

    • Synovial PMN Percentage: Greater than 80%.

Technique / Principles: Stepwise Diagnostic Algorithm

Step 1: High Index of Suspicion & Clinical Evaluation

  • Suspect PJI in every painful prosthetic joint, regardless of apparent mechanical failure or ALTR.

  • Evaluate history and physical examination for wound-related complications, persistent postoperative pain, or failure to progress after arthroplasty.

Step 2: First-Line Serological Screening

  • Obtain ESR and CRP (with D-dimer as an optional adjunct) prior to any revision surgery or before ruling out infection.

  • Normal Serology Rule: If ESR and CRP are normal and clinical suspicion is low, infection can generally be excluded. However, 11% of patients with true PJI present with normal ESR and CRP; therefore, high clinical suspicion overrides normal blood markers and mandates joint aspiration.

Step 3: Synovial Fluid Aspiration & Analysis

  • Antibiotic Hold: Ensure the patient is strictly off antibiotics prior to aspiration until infection is confirmed or excluded.

  • Surgeon-Performed Aspiration: The orthopedic surgeon should perform the aspiration directly (in the clinic or block room) rather than delegating routinely to radiology.

  • Mandatory Synovial Tests: Send fluid for synovial WBC count, PMN differential percentage, and culture (with leukocyte esterase as an optional rapid adjunct).

  • Role of Alpha-Defensin (Speaker’s Practice): Based on studies by Jason Jennings and Robin Patel (Mayo Clinic), if sufficient synovial fluid is obtained to perform a standard cell count and neutrophil differential, alpha-defensin testing provides no added diagnostic benefit and is unnecessary.

Step 4: Managing a “Dry Tap”

  • Do Not Instill Saline: Never inject or lavage normal saline into a dry joint to obtain fluid; saline dilution invalidates cell counts and neutrophil differentials (90% consensus agreement).

  • Escalation Pathway for Dry Aspiration:

    1. Bring the patient back for a repeat aspiration attempt.

    2. If still dry, proceed either to image-guided aspiration (under ultrasound or CT guidance, as practiced by Luigi Zagra) or open tissue biopsy (as practiced at the ENDO-Klinik). (Note: The speaker states he never orders nuclear bone scans).

Step 5: Extended Cultures & Molecular Diagnostics

  • Two-Week Culture Incubation: Maintain microbiological cultures for a full 2 weeks (14 days) whenever PJI is suspected to capture slow-growing, indolent organisms (consensus mandate).

  • Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) / Metagenomics: For culture-negative cases, utilize NGS (or hybrid NGS/metagenomics), which carries 92% consensus agreement. Unlike targeted PCR—which requires organism-specific primers—NGS detects all microbial genetic material in the sample and identifies polymicrobial infections.

Complications / Limitations

  • False-Negative Serology (11%): Normal ESR and CRP do not exclude low-grade or indolent PJI.

  • False-Negative Cultures (20%–40%): Prior antibiotic exposure, short incubation times (<14 days), biofilm sequestration, and fastidious organisms (98% of bacteria do not grow on standard media) frequently yield negative cultures despite active infection.

  • Saline Lavage Artifact: Instilling saline during a dry tap ruins synovial fluid cellular thresholds and yields false-negative results.

Practical Clinical Implications

  • Never perform a “simple” polyethylene exchange, arthroscopy, or mechanical revision on a painful arthroplasty without completing a formal preoperative PJI workup.

  • Always verify laboratory units for CRP (mg/L vs. mg/dL) when applying the 10 mg/L (chronic) and 100 mg/L (acute) thresholds.

  • When synovial fluid volume permits a standard synovial WBC count and PMN percentage, skip expensive alpha-defensin assays.

  • Ensure microbiology laboratories hold prosthetic joint aspirates and tissue samples for 14 days, and utilize Next-Generation Sequencing when clinical and synovial markers indicate PJI despite negative cultures.

Key Take-Home Points

  • Universal Suspicion: Suspect PJI in every painful joint replacement—even when aseptic loosening, wear, or metal-on-metal ALTR (which carries a 9–14× higher infection risk) is present.

  • Serology Caveat: Obtain ESR and CRP first, but remember 11% of PJI patients have normal inflammatory markers; clinical suspicion always mandates aspiration.

  • ICM Diagnostic Cutoffs:

    • Acute PJI: CRP >100 mg/L, Synovial WBC >10,000, PMN >90% (ESR not useful).

    • Chronic PJI: ESR >30 mm/hr, CRP >10 mg/L, Synovial WBC >3,000, PMN >80%.

  • Aspiration Rules: Hold all antibiotics prior to sampling; never instill normal saline into a dry joint (90% consensus); skip alpha-defensin when adequate fluid is available for cell count and differential.

  • Overcoming Culture-Negative PJI: Cultures miss 20%–40% of infections; hold cultures for 2 weeks and deploy Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) (92% consensus) to detect fastidious and polymicrobial pathogens.

Post Views: 1,841

Related Posts

  • Irreparable massive rotator cuff tears Managed with Lower Trapezius tendon transfer

    Courtesy: Emmanouil Brilakis, Bassam ElHassan, Athens Shoulder Course Topic / Overview Biomechanical rationale, patient selection,…

  • Functional Alignment TKA for Complex Deformities

    Courtesy: Heiko Grachen, Ashok Shyam, IORG, OrthoTV Topic / Overview Intraoperative workflow, Laxity Phenotype Classification,…

  • Laving the Canal in Revision Shoulder Arthroplasty

    Courtesy: Surena Namdari, Rothmans Institute, Philadelphia

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. admin says

    at

    Also read,
    Wysowski DK. Reports of esophageal cancer with oral bisphosphonate use. N Engl J Med2009;360:89-90.

  2. bimal says

    at

    few things to be noted

    1) being a case control study, the problem of bias is to be kept in mind. plus expecting a high evidence study in this topic may not be realistic cuz of the low incidence of the problem (1% in gen population )

    2) study itself mentions the inability to find out whether the patients were told bt upper GI safe guard measures ( to take it with plenty of water in empty stomach and to avoid lying down for 30 mts)

    3) the confidence limits and intervals of relative risks of associated factors tells us few points
    be careful in old patients who has previous h/o gastritis, GERD, smokers or alcoholics (alcoholics more dangerous). concurrents antacids not a bad idea. and always follow the upper GI safeguard tips

  3. bimal says

    at

    also would like to add a cohort study which showed that there s no increase in risk ,,so we will have to wait for a final statement.

    http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/abstract/304/6/657?maxtoshow&hits=10&RESULTFORMAT&fulltext=bisphosphonate&searchid=1&FIRSTINDEX=0&resourcetype=HWCIT

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Follow Us

instagram slideshare

Categories

  • -Applied Anatomy
  • -Approaches
  • -Basic Sciences
  • -Cartilage & Meniscus
  • -Classifications
  • -Examination
  • -Foot and Ankle
  • -Foot and Ankle Trauma
  • -FRCS(Tr and Orth) tutorials
  • -Gait
  • -Hand and Wrist
  • -Hand and Wrist Trauma
  • -Hand Infections
  • -Hip and Knee
  • -Hip Preservation
  • -Infections
  • -Joint Reconstruction
  • -Knee Arthroplasty
  • -Knee Preservation
  • -Metabolic Disorders
  • -Oncology
  • -OrthoBiologics
  • -OrthoPlastic
  • -Paediatric Orthopaedics
  • -Paediatric Trauma
  • -Patellofemoral Joint
  • -Pelvis
  • -Peripheral Nerves
  • -Principles
  • -Principles of Surgery
  • -Radiology
  • -Rheumatology
  • -Shoulder and Elbow
  • -Shoulder and Elbow Arthroplasty
  • -Spine Deformity
  • -Spine Oncology
  • -Spine Trauma
  • -Spine, Pelvis & Neurology
  • -Sports Ankle and Foot
  • -Sports Elbow
  • -Sports Knee
  • -Sports Medicine
  • -Sports Medicine Hip
  • -Sports Shoulder
  • -Sports Wrist
  • -Statistics
  • -Technical Tip
  • -Technology in Orth
  • -Trauma
  • -Trauma (Upper Limb)
  • -Trauma Life Support
  • -Trauma Reconstruction
  • Book Shelf
  • Book Shelf Medical
  • Careers
  • Case Studies and Free Papers
  • DNB Ortho
  • Evidence Based Orthopaedic Principles
  • Evidence Based Orthopaedics
  • Exam Corner
  • Fellowships
  • Guest Editor
  • Guest Reviews
  • Image Quiz
  • Instructional Course Lectures
  • Journal Club
  • MCQs
  • Meetings and Courses
  • MS Ortho
  • Multimedia
  • News and Blog
  • Plaster Techniques
  • Podcasts
  • Public Health
  • Rehabilitation
  • Research
  • Shorts and Reels
Copyright@orthopaedicprinciples.com. All right rerserved.